Best Omelette Pan 2020: Reviews + Buying Guide

If you really care about the quality of your cooking, then you might want to consider investing in a good omelette pan.

These helpful pieces of cookware, contrary to what the name might indicate, are not just for egg dishes. Instead, they are designed to be used for cooking any sort of item that requires skillful maneuvering to avoid burning.

The most classic example is the omelette, but other dishes that you might want to cook in these pans include pancakes, fish, and similar dishes.

If you are interested in getting an Omelette pan, then you have come to the right place as we will be reviewing a bunch of really good options in this article.

If you want to buy right now, we think that the best omelette pan is the Calphalon Contemporary Omelette Fry Pan.

A Spotlight On Some of The Best Omelette Pan 2020:

 

Cooks Standard Omelet Pan

We wanted to start off this review list with a fairly standard, but also pretty well-made omelette pan. We will be reviewing some specialty pans later on in this list, but to kick it off, we wanted to look at a normal option that also functions as a good omelette pan.

The pan that we ultimately decided to review was the Cooks Standard Omelet Pan. This is the perfect single pan to add to any kitchen collection because it makes cooking a bunch of different dishes a lot easier.

So, since this pan doesn’t feature any unique shapes or gimmicks, you might be curious what it is that actually qualifies the Cooks Standard Omelet Pan as being good for omelettes. Well, there are a few different things about the Cooks Standard that make it a good option that we want to highlight.

The first thing that we want to draw your attention is the even heating that you get from this pan. Omelettes are extremely prone to burning if they are cooked in a pan that doesn’t heat evenly. The solid anodized aluminum bottom ensures that heat is distributed evenly and that every dish is cooked evenly. It makes this pan a great option for anything that needs to be cooked evenly and quickly (fish, egg dishes, etc.).

Of course, another important aspect of this pan that helps to make it suited for cooking things like omelettes is the fact that it has a really good nonstick cooking surface.

The smooth black cooking surface is naturally nonstick, which is great for cooking omelettes since it ensures that your eggs always slide right off the pan and onto your plate. The same goes for other types of food as well. You will never have to deal with burnt or unevenly cooked eggs again.

Finally, we also want to mention that this is, in general, a very well-made and durable piece of cookware. Even when compared to other omelette pans, this one stands out. As an example of this, take the fact that this is actually oven safe up to a temperature of around 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which is pretty rare for an omelette pan.

Norpro Nonstick Omelet Pan

For the next review on our best omelette pan list is special because it is the first two-sided pan that we are taking a look at on this list. See, you may not know this until you read our buying guide below, but there are many different types of omelette pans out there.

Some are just shaped like regular omelette pans, while others are shaped like the Norpro. Since this is a common type of omelette pan that you will see online, we wanted to make sure that we reviewed at least one or two of these types of pans.

For those unfamiliar with two-sided pans, you can probably guess how they work just based on how they look, but let’s go into a bit more detail. Unlike other types of “omelette” pans, two-sided pans are really only intended for omelettes (or other similar eggs dishes).

What you do is cook one side of the omelette in one part of the pan and the other part of the omelette in the other side. You just then flip the pan closed and the top of the omelette slips onto the bottom part.

It is a novelty item to be sure, but if you are the type who is constantly cooking omelettes or frittatas and you really want to make sure that you get them correct every single time, then something like the Norpro Nonstick Omelet Pan can be a real help.

Of course, in order to work properly, the Norpro has to be designed with nonstick interiors to ensure that the egg always slips out. So, you can rest easy knowing that each side of this pan has a really well-made, reliably nonstick interior.

While we do think that the unique design of the Norpro certainly helps when it comes to making egg dishes like omelettes and frittatas, it does have a downside, and it is the same downside that impacts all pans of this type.

The downside that we are talking about is the fact that this type of pan, unlike the other types that we have reviewed, are not quite as good for things besides omelettes. The two sided design just isn’t good for things like pancakes or fish.

Calphalon Contemporary Omelette Fry Pan

The next pan that we want to do a review of on this article is going to be a real treat because as you are going to see in our review, the Calphalon is one of the best quality omelette pans out there, and its sheer quality really makes it stand out on this list. If we had to pick a single option to label as the “best omelette pan,” we would, without a doubt, pick this one.

There are a lot of really good things to like about the Calphalon, but why don’t we start with the sheer construction quality of this pan. There are no two ways about it, this is an extremely well-made, and solid pan. It is a bit heavier than your average omelette pan, which is a downside, but it is an otherwise very well-crafted and durable piece of cookware.

Now, those of you who are familiar with this particular brand of cookware will know that their pans tend to both have very good nonstick properties and heat evenly. Both of these things are once again true with the Calphalon Contemporary. It always heats perfectly and the food slides right off of it.

ESLITE LIFE Tamagoyaki Pan

Continuing on with our trend of reviewing 1sts, let’s take a look at the first Japanese style omelette pan that we are reviewing on our best omelette pan list. While most people wouldn’t typically associate Japan with omelettes, the reality is that they actually make their own version of omelettes and they are very popular both in Japan and abroad.

The major difference is that Japanese omelettes tend to be square, as opposed to round. As such, Japanese cooks sued their own specialized version of omelette pans. We figured that we would include one such example of this on our review list because they are becoming more popular in the West.

While there are quite a few Japanese style pans out there, the one that we think is most deserving of being on this list is the ESLITE LIFE Tamagoyaki Pan.

The first thing that we should talk about in this review is what the advantage of this pan’s unique shape is, since that is obviously very important. The square shape of the pan is such a big deal because it allows you to more easily shape your omelette and to slide it out.

While it can take a bit to get used to, once you are familiar with cooking in a square pan, we are sure that most of you will come to like it. This is helped out by the fact that the ESLITE LIFE Tamagoyaki Pan has a really good, nonstick interior that makes cooking a perfect (if a bit oddly shaped) omelette even easier.

As with all specialty pans such as this, the thing that makes it special (such as the unique shape) can be a bit of a problem since it takes a while to get used to. You saw this with the Norpro that we reviewed earlier, and it applies to the ESLITE as well. The square shape has a lot of advantages, most of which we mentioned in the review, but if this is your first exposure to a Japanese style omelette pan, then it is going to take quite a bit to get used to, which is something that we would warn people about before they buy this.

Carote Granite Omelet Pan

For the last review on our best omelette pan list, we are going to be doing a review of another relatively normal pan in the form of the Carote Granite Omelet Pan. To kick off the review list, we took a look at a very normal pan, and so we felt that there was no better way to end the review list then by doing the same.

As you can probably see for yourself, the Carote is shaped like a fairly normal piece of cookware, which will probably lead to the question of why this is actually appearing in the first place. Well, there are a few things to note.

First off, the Carote heats very evenly, which as we mentioned earlier on in the article is extremely important when it comes to finding a good omelette pan.

Aside from the wooden handle (which we will discuss shortly), by far the most unique aspect of this pan is its granite coating. This coating does a few good things. First off, it is scratch resistant, so it helps to make the pan more durable. Secondly, the granite coating is naturally nonstick, so it makes the pan easier to cook with. Finally, granite washes easily, so cleaning the pan is less of a hassle. The granite coating is really fantastic and we can’t stress enough that this coating is a big part of the reason why the Carote is appearing on our review list.

We do have one, super small complaint with the Carote, which is that the pan could afford to be a bit better when it comes to the wooden handle that is attached to the pan. On the one hand, the wooden handle doesn’t heat up like metal does, which is nice. On the other hand, the wooden handle isn’t quite as well-made as we would hope, and it wears out pretty quickly after it gets washed.

Omelette Pans: What To Look For and Some Helpful Tips

We aren’t going to tell you that buying an omelette pan is hard, because it really isn’t. If you know how to buy a single piece of cookware, then you know broadly what to look for when it comes to buying an omelette pan.

However, it is still fair to say, in our opinion, that these are not exactly the most common products around. A lot of people probably don’t even know what omelette pans are, and many fewer actually have one in their cupboards.

So, those of you reading through this article probably have some questions that need answering. We plan to help you out with this buying guide. In this guide, you will find information about omelette pans (it should answer all of your questions and then some), as well as some helpful tips to keep in mind when buying.

Even Heating

 

If we had to pick two criteria that were more important than anything else when it comes to picking out a good omelette pan, we would have to pick even heating and nonstick surfaces (both are equally important and choosing which of the two is more crucial would be impossible). So, let’s start off by discussing the first criteria, which is even heating.

The reason why an omelette pan has to heat evenly is because the types of things that one cooks in an omelette pan are food items that tend to cook quickly (omelettes, fish, pancakes, thin pieces of meat, etc.).

Since these items cook so quickly, if one part of the pan is hotter than the other parts, your item won’t cook properly. Have you ever gotten an omelette where one part seems to be cooked quite a lot and has a crust on it, while other parts of the omelette are creamy and undercooked? That’s because the omelette was cooked in a pan that doesn’t heat evenly.

To tell if a particular pan will heat evenly, make sure that it has a nice, flat bottom. Also, make sure that it is made from a material that is a good conductor of heat, like aluminum or copper.

Nonstick Surface

 

The next most important criteria is the presence of a good nonstick surface. This is probably a bit more self-evident than even heating, but let’s still go over it.

As you can probably guess, you want a nonstick surface because many dishes are prone to sticking and breaking apart when cooked. We are sure that many of you reading this list have lost otherwise perfect omelettes to sticking. There is absolutely nothing worse than going to flip and omelette, only to have it fall apart in the pan. This also applies to other food items as well.

Ideally, you want a pan with a durable nonstick coating that isn’t going to wear off or be reduced in effectiveness as the pan gets washed. On our best omelette pan review list, we reviewed a bunch of different good nonstick options, so you will be fine as long as you pick one of the pans that we recommended.

Conclusion

 

If you are still curious about any part of our review list, go ahead and leave your question down in our best omelette pan comment section.